Madariaga - College of Europe Foundation

The Citizen's Controversies* series of lunchtime debates seek to address one of Europe’s most vital tasks: rekindling the citizen’s interest in EU matters. Much has been said about the ‘democratic deficit’, which is now felt to seriously hamper EU progress.  This deficit, however, does not stem from undemocratic EU institutions, but from a lack of citizen participation in EU democratic life. Less an institutional deficit, therefore, than a citizenship deficit. The Citizen's Controversies strive to encourage citizens’ ownership of the pan-European political debate by securing fair and contrasting views on fundamental EU issues. Each debate confronts different points of view on a given topic to point out options and trade-offs and highlight the political stakes present in each necessary compromise. The objective, in sum, is to enhance the perception of a ‘European common good’, which is more than the sum of national interests.

* The Citizen's Controversies are held under the Chatham House Rule. A report is then published after agreement with the speakers.

Related Events and Reports:  

Peut-on remodeler le capitalisme de marché? 10 juin 2013

With Nicole Dewandre, European Commission, and Bruno Colmant, Royal Academy of Belgium.

Is the Fragmentation of the Food Chain doing more Harm than Good? 29 May 2013

With Monique Goyens, Director General of the European Consumer Organisation, and Ladislav Miko, Deputy Director General for Food Chain, DG Health and Consumers. 

Beyond the Accounting and Transparency Directives: Towards Binding Norms for Conflict Minerals? 15 May 2013

With Judith Sargentini, MEP (Greens), and Andrew Bone, Director for International Relations, De Beers.  

 Report 

How to Overcome Regulatory Fragmentation for European Telecoms? 17 April 2013

With Andrea Renda, Professor  of Economic Analysis of Law, LUISS University, and Marc Lebourges, Head of France Telecom's EU Regulatory Affairs.  

Le budget européen: tremplin ou impasse pour le Parlement européen? 8 avril 2013

Avec Jean-Luc Dehaene, Membre du Parlement européen, et Philippe Etienne, Ambassadeur, Représentant Permanent de la France auprès de l'Union européenne. 

 Rapport 

Is the Crisis Turning the Precariat Into the New Proletariat? 4 April 2013

With Guy Standing, Professor of Economic Security at the University of Bath, and Denis Pennel, Managing Director of Eurociett - European Confederation of Private Employment Agencies.  

 Report 

Debt Mutualisation: Breaking the Taboo? 21 March 2013

With Sylvie Goulard, Member of the European Parliament (ALDE), and Ansgar Belke, Professor of Macroeconomics at the University of Duisburg-Essen.  

 Report 

Will the Multilateral Trading System Resist the Crisis? 7 March 2013

With Ditte Juul-Joergensen, Director for WTO, legal affairs and trade in goods, European Commission, and Roderick Abbott, Member of the Advisory Board of the European Centre for International Political Economy (ECIPE).  

   Report 

Does the EU have an Ambitious Enough Strategy for Outer Space? 25 February 2013

With Kai-Uwe Schrogl, Head of the Policies Department, European Space Agency, and Frank Slijper, Senior Researcher, Transnational Institute.

  Report  

Is Germany Buying Cheap Discipline? 7 February 2013

With Ronald Janssen, Senior Economic Advisor, European Trade Unions Confederation (ETUC), and Ognian Hishow, Senior Associate, German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP).  

 Report 

Does the ESM Need a Bank Licence? 6 February 2012

With Angelo Baglioni, Professor of Microeconomics and Economics of Information at the Catholic University of Milan, and Rolf Strauch, Responsible for Economics and Policy Strategy at the European Stability Mechanism (ESM).  

  Report  

Children and the Internet: What Trade-off between Freedom and Safety? 31 January 2013

With Robert Madelin, Director General of the DG Connect, European Commission, and Christian Engström, Member of the European Parliament (The Greens/European Free Alliance).

  Report 

A Volcker Rule for Europe? Assessing the Liikanen Report 22 January 2013

With Philippe Lamberts, Member of the European Parliament, and Michiel Bijlsma, Director for Finance, Dutch Central Planbureau. 

 Report 

Is Europe Ready for an American Disengagement? 8 January 2013

With Jamie Shea, Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges, NATO, and Sven Biscop, Director, Egmont Institute. 

  Report

The New European Trade Strategy: Towards a Mercantilist Revival? 11 December 2012

With Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, Director, European Centre for International Political Economy (ECIPE), and Denis Redonnet, Head of Unit, Trade Strategy, DG Trade, European Commission.

 Report 

Energy Transition: Japanese and European Perspectives 10 December 2012

With Ambassador Kojiro Shiojiri, Mission of Japan to the European Union, and Philip Lowe, Director General, DG Energy, European Commission.

   Report 

Can Austerity be Expansionary in Present Europe? 23 November 2012

With Lennart Erixon, Professor of Macroeconomics, University of Stockholm, and Achim Truger, Professor of Economics, Berlin School of Economics and Law.

  Report 

European Economic Governance: Towards Which Banking Union? 12 November 2012

With Eric De Keuleneer, Professor of Finance, Solvay Business School, and Nicolas Véron, Senior Fellow, Bruegel. 

  Report 

Décrypter le fil rouge de François Hollande 6 novembre 2012

Avec Jacques Mistral, Directeur des Etudes Economiques auprès de l'Institut Français des Relations Internationales (Ifri), et Xavier Timbeau, Directeur du Département Analyse et Prévision au sein de l'Observatoire Français des Conjonctures Economiques (OFCE).

 Rapport

Flexicurity Is Dead, Long Live Flexicurity? 22 October 2012

With Jean-Louis De Brouwer, Director for Employment Policies, DG Employment and Social Affairs of the European Commission, and Andranik Tangian, Head of Policy Modelling at the Hans Boeckler Stiftung. 

What Went Wrong with the ECB? 11 July 2012

With Cinzia Alcidi, Research Fellow, CEPS, and Philippe Legrain, Principal Adviser and Head of the Analysis Team, BEPA.

  Report

The Bank Resolution Fund: For the EU or for the Eurozone? 10 July 2012

With Mario Nava, Director for Financial Institutions, DG MARKT, European Commission, and Dirk Schoenmaker, Dean of the Duisenberg School of Finance.

  Report   

Is China Already a Market Economy? What Implications for the EU's Trade Defence Policy? 22 June 2012

With Sylvain Plasschaert, Professor Emeritus, Catholic University of Leuven (KUL), and Inès Van Lierde, Chair of the BusinessEurope Trade Defence Instruments' Group.

  Report

How to Tackle Rising Inequalities in Europe? 14 June 2012

With Ana Llena-Nozal, Economist, OECD; and Wojtek Kalinowski, Director, Veblen Institute for Economic Reform.

  Report

Is the Crisis of Europe the Crisis of Social Democracy? 6 June 2012

With Paul Magnette, Belgian Minister for Public Enterprises, Scientific Policy and Development Cooperation; and Luke Martell, Professor of Political Sociology, University of Sussex. 

  Report

Is Europe Serious About Financial Regulation? The Ban on CDS Naked Short-Selling as a Test Case 5 June 2012

With Philip Tod, Senior Administrator, Securities Markets Unit, DG MARKT, European Commission, and Diego Valiante, CEPS Research Fellow and ECMI Head of Research.

  Report

What are the Risks of Small Steps in a Rapidly Changing World? 2 May 2012

With Luuk Van Middelaar, political philosopher and historian, Member of the Cabinet of Herman Van Rompuy and author of the book Passage à l’Europe (Gallimard, 2012); and Yves Bertoncini, Secretary General of Notre Europe and author of the book Politique européenne : Etats, pouvoirs et citoyens de l’UE (Sciences-Po and Dalloz, 2010).

  Report

A Good Use of Treaties in Economic Policy: What Effectiveness and What Legitimacy? 25 April 2012

With Odile Renaud-Basso, Deputy Head of Cabinet – Cabinet of the President Herman Van Rompuy, Council of the European Union; and, Jean-Victor Louis, Professor Emeritus, Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB).

  Report

The American and Chinese Views on the Euro Crisis 15 March 2012 

With Federico Rampini, La Repubblica's New York Bureau Chief, former columnist and correspondent in Beijing, Stephen Fidler, Head of the Brussels Office of the Wall Street Journal and Xiang Lanxin, Professor in International History and Politics, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (Geneva).

   Report

La crise de l'eurozone: entre désintégration et fédéralisation 28 February 2012

Avec Michel Aglietta, Professeur d’économie (Université de Paris X) et conseiller scientifique au Centre d’études prospectives et d’informations internationales (CEPII), auteur de « Zone euro : éclatement ou fédération » (Michalon, 2012), et Guillaume Sarlat, Inspecteur des finances et ancien Rapporteur de la Commission sur la dette publique française.

  Rapport

How to Switch from Jobless Growth to Growthless Jobs? 21 February 2012

With Stefano Scarpetta, Head of Employment Analysis and Policy Division (OECD), and Joep Konings, Professor at the Faculty of Business and Economics, Catholic University of Leuven.

  Report

The Impact of the Crisis on Regional and Local Finances: Any Role for the Next Multi-Annual Financial Framework? 7 February 2012

With Fabien Zuleeg, Chief Economist, European Policy Centre, Michael Ralph, Adviser to the Director General, DG REGIO, European Commission and Jorge Nunez Ferrer, Associate Research Fellow, Centre for European Policy Studies.

  Report

What Trade-off between Air Mobility and Climate Change Mitigation? 1 February 2012

With Peter Liese, MEP (EPP), Member of the European Parliament's Committee of the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety, and Ulrich Schulte-Strathaus, Secretary-General of the Association of European Airlines (AEA).

  Report

GMOs: A Fair Case for Subsidiarity? 24 January 2012

With Ladislav Miko, Deputy Director General at DG Health and Consumers, European Commission, and Corinne Lepage, MEP (ALDE) and Member of the European Parliament's Environment, Public health and Food Safety Committee.

  Report    Rapport

Is Europe Heading Towards Another Wave of Recapitalisation, and Who is Going to Pay this Time? 20 December 2011

With Guido Ravoet, Secretary General of the European Banking Federation, and Jean-Paul Gauzès, MEP (EPP), coordinator whitin the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee. 

Rapport

Le mission de l'OTAN en Libye: quel impact sur la défense européenne? 15 December 2011 

With Jean-Paul Perruche, Director of Studies at the Institut de Recherche Stratégique de l'Ecole Militaire (IRSEM) and former Director General of the EU Military Staff, and Philippe Errera, French Permanent Representative to NATO.

  Rapport    Report

The Golden Rule on Debt Ceilings: Necessary, Useful or Dangerous? 1 December 2011

With Lars Feld, Professor of Economic Policy at the University of Freiburg and Member of the German Council of Economic Experts, and Ann Pettifor, Director of PRIME – Policy Research in Macroeconomic and Fellow at the New Economics Foundation.

  Report

Schengen in trouble: Is Europe Still Able to Defend its Acquis? 22 November 2011

With Henrik Nielsen, Head of Unit for Border Management and Return Policy, DG Home Affairs (European Commission), and Sergio Carrera, Senior Research Fellow and Head of the Justice and Home Affairs Programme (CEPS).

  Report

What Order of Priorities for the Common Fisheries Policy Reform? 9 November 2011

With Lowri Evans, Director General of DG for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, and Alain Cadec, Vice-chairman of the European Parliament's Fisheries Committee (MEP, EPP).

  Report      Rapport

With Karl Falkenberg, Director General of DG Environment, European Commission, and Claude Turmes, MEP (Greens/EFA).

  Report

What do the 'Indignados' have to say to the EU? What does the EU have to say to the 'Indignados'? 19 October 2011

With Koos Richelle, Director General of DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, and Olivier Bourgeois, Member of the International Commission of the Indignados Movement.

  Report

With Ludo Vekemans, Adviser-Director at ETUC/SDA, and Theo Keijzer, Chairman of ICC Taxation Commission and Founder of Dorean Tax Policy B.V.. The debate will be chaired by Walter Deffaa, Director General of DG Taxation and Customs Union, European Commission.

With Philippe Maystadt, President of the European Investment Bank, and Christian Saint-Etienne, professeur titulaire de la Chaire d'Economie industrielle au Conservatoire national des Arts et Métiers.

Rapport

With Pervenche Berès, MEP (S&D), Rapporteur of the Special Committee on the Financial, Economic and Social Crisis, and Sirpa Pietikäinen, MEP (EPP).

  Report

With Paul Jorion, anthropologist-economist and essayist, and Jean-Jacques Lambin, Professor Emeritus at the Catholic University of Louvain and at the Milano-Bicocca University.

Rapport

With Andrew Duff, MEP, Member of the Committee on Constitutional Affairs, and Paolo Ponzano, Senior Fellow at the European University Institute, Florence.

 Report

With Csaba Öry, MEP (EPP), Member of the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs, and Georges Lemaitre, International Migration Expert, OECD. Moderator: Anaïs Faure Atger, Researcher, CEPS.

Rapport

With Gilles Lepesant, geographer and Research Fellow at the CNRS and Paweł Świeboda, President of demosEUROPA - Centre for European Strategy.

  Report

With Sharon Bowles, Member of the European Parliament (ALDE), Chair of the Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, and Alexandre Lamfalussy, Economist, former President of the European Monetary Institute.

  Report

With Catherine Locatelli, Research Fellow, CNRS, and Philip Lowe, Director General for Energy, European Commission

  Rapport

With Jean-Philippe Béja, Research Director at the CNRS/CERI-Sciences-Po (Paris) and Shujie Yao, Director of the School of Contemporary Chinese Studies, University of Nottingham

  Report

With Henri Sterdyniak, Director of the Economics of Globalisation Department, OFCE, and André Sapir, Senior Fellow, Bruegel

 Rapport

With Philippe de Buck, Secretary General of Business Europe, and John Monks, General Secretary of the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC).

With José-Manuel Nobre-Correia, Professor of History and Socio-economy of the Media (ULB) and Robert Madelin, Director General for Information Society and Media, European Commission.

With Marek Dabrowski, President of the Center for Social and Economic Research (CASE) in Warsaw, and György Surányi, Head of Central and Eastern Europe Region, Intesa Sanpaolo Group, former President of the National Bank of Hungary.

With Pieter De Crem, Belgian Minister of Defence, and Lt. General David Leakey, former Director General of the EU Military Staff, Council of the European Union.

  Report

With Hugues Dumont, Professor of Constitutional Law, Université Catholique de Louvain; President of the Institute of European Studies, Facultés Universitaires Saint-Louis, and Marc Reynebeau,  journalist and historian, columnist at De Standaard. Moderated by Jean-Pierre Stroobants, Brussels' correspondent for Le Monde.

  Rapport

With Nicole Gnesotto, Professor at the Conservatoire national des Arts et Métiers, and Robert Cooper, Director General for External and Political-Military Affairs, Council of the European Union.

Report

With Elie Barnavi, Historian, Scientific Director of the Museum of Europe, and Hélène Flautre, MEP (Greens/ EFA), Chair of the Chair of the Delegation to the EU-Turkey Joint Parliamentary Committee.

 Rapport

With David Wright, deputy Director General,DG Internal Market and Services, European Commission, and Roger Cogan, European Policy Director, International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA).

With Philippe Lamberts, MEP (Greens/ EFA), and Olivier Bailly, Head of Unit, Spokespersons' Service, European Commission.

 Rapport

With Stéphane Le Foll, MEP (S&D), and Jorge Núñez Ferrer, Associate Research Fellow, CEPS.

  Report

With Wolfgang Munchau, Financial Times columnist, and André Sapir, Professor of Economics at the ULB and Senior Fellow at Bruegel.

Report

With Hervé Jouanjean, Director General for DG Budget, European Commission, and Jean-Luc Dehaene, MEP, Vice-Chairman of the European Parliament's Budget Committee.

 Rapport

With David O'Sullivan, Director General for Trade, European Commission, and Simon J. Evenett, Professor of International Trade and Economic Development and Director of the Swiss Institute for International Economics and Applied Economic Research at the University of St Gallen, Switzerland

  Report

With Esperanza Durán, Executive Director of AITIC, and Denis Redonnet, Head of Unit for WTO and OCDE cooperation, DG Trade, European Commission.

  Report

With Ernst Stetter, Secretary General of the Foundation for European Progressive Studies (FEPS), and Philippe Marlière, Reader in French and European Politics at the University College, London (UCL).

 Report                      Philippe Marlière's speech                     Ernst Stetter's speech

With Huang Huabo, First Secretary General at the Chinese Mission to the EU and Robert Verrue, Director General for Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunies, European Commission.

 Report

With Stefano Manservisi, Director General for Development, European Commission, and Theodore Trefon, Director of the Belgian Reference Centre for Expertise for Central Africa and Head of the Contemporary History Section of the Royal Museum for Central Africa in Tervuren.

  Rapport

With Elisa Ferreira, MEP (S&D) and Michael Vercnocke, Head of European Affairs of the City Office in Brussels.

 Report

With Piotr Maciej Kaczynski, Research Fellow at CEPS, and Jean-Victor Louis, Honorary Professor at the ULB.

 Report

With Eva Joly, MEP, Chairwoman of the Committee on Development.

 Report

With Nicolas Véron, Research Fellow at Bruegel, and Andrew Watt, Senior Researcher at the European Trade Union Institute (ETUI).

 Report

With Alexandre Lamfalussy, European economist, and Nicolas Véron, Research Fellow at Bruegel.

 Rapport

With Véronique de Keyser, MEP, Vice-President of the Alliance of Socialists and Democrats, Iñigo Méndez de Vigo, MEP, European People's Party.

 Rapport

With David Rennie, EU correspondent for The Economist, and Jean Quatremer, EU correspondent for Libération.

 Rapport

With Ambassador Benoît d'Aboville, Former French Ambassador to NATO (2002-2005), and Jean-Luc Dehaene, President of the Administrative Council of the College of Europe, Member of the European Parliament.

 Rapport

With Daniel Gros, Director of the Centre for European Policy Studies (CEPS).

 Report

With Wolfgang Munchau, Financial Times columnist, and Thomas Westphal, Head of the Financial Affairs Unit, Permanent Representation of Germany to the EU.

  Report 

With Robert Madelin, Director General of the Health and Consumers DG, European Commission, and Karsten Uno Petersen, Member of the South Denmark Regional Council, Committee of the Regions' rapporteur on the draft directive on cross-border healthcare.

With Prof. Paul De Grauwe, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Dr Feng San, Economic Officer at the Chinese Mission to the EU and Mr David Lippeatt, Chief of Economic Policy Unit, US Mission to the EU. 

 Report

With Jean-Arnold Vinois, Head of Unit, Energy Policy and Security of Supply, DG TREN, European Commission, and Fabio Marchetti, Head of Delegation to the EU, ENI. 

 Report

With Paul Magnette, Belgian Federal Minester of Energy and Climate, and Philippe de Buck, Director General of Business Europe.

  Rapport

With Nicolas Véron, Research Fellow and Chief Development Officer of Bruegel, and Francis Wurtz, MEP, Confederal Group of the European United Left - Nordic Green Left.

 Report

With Emmanuel Julien, Deputy Director of the MEDEF's Direction of Labour Relations, to the ones of Philippe Pochet, General Director of ETUI-REHS.

  Report

With Benoît Hamon, Member of the Socialist Group in the European Parliament, and Iñigo Méndez de Vigo, Member of the European Parliament's Group of the European People's Party (Christian Democrats) and European Democrats.

 Report